Mixing Bagel Dough

Context, I've had my mixer for less than a week, so learning how to use it.

My specific question relates to making a 58% hydration bagel dough. Following the instructions to add liquid first then dry ingredients, there is way more flour than liquid so the dough stays very floury. With alot of scraping the roller and manipulating the dough I eventually get the dough into a cohesive ball and I'm able to kneed it from there.

I assume this is just the way it is with this kind of low hydration dough just wondering if you have suggestions.

Thanks

Roger
Roger

Comments

  • Hi Roger,

    I would suggest to go very easy on adding flour when doing low hydration. Add half of the flour first, and keep adding in small increments until the dough starts forming. Then keep adding and waiting until the flour is incorporated before you add more. That way you avoid having to manually intervene like how you described in your post.
    Johan Customer Service
  • Hi, can you guys get back in touch with Roger and ask him how the bagel dough mixing is working out? I'm considering buying one of these mixers, but I really only need it for my 60% hydration bagel dough. I'd like to know if he's been successful with his bagel dough in this machine. If he agrees to contact with me directly, feel free to give him my contact info. Thanks.
    Andy Sagan
  • As far as the mixer's resilience to low hydration, stiff dough... do you foresee any problems (bagel dough is too stiff for a KitchenAid, will burn out the motor). Thanks.
    Andy Sagan
  • Hi Andy,

    at 60% hydration it's usually no problem kneading the dough, as I replied to Roger, you need to go slow with adding flour when doing low hydration to let the mixer incorporate the flour.

    As the mixer needs friction to work the dough, going to low will result in no friction between the dough and the bowl. I tend to see issues at 55% and below. I tend to modify these recipes to a slightly higher hydration level.
    Johan Customer Service

Add your comment or create a new post

Your name and post can be seen by everyone.Your e-mail will never be shown publicly.